jump to navigation

Assignment Zero August 17, 2007

Posted by Steve Field in Assignment Zero.

I had never heard of Assignment Zero until it was mentioned in class on Monday.

So I shouldn’t have had any expectations. Still, I was surprised to see what I found.

Assignment Zero describes itself as the following:

Inspired by the open-source movement, this is an attempt to bring journalists together with people in the public who can help cover a story. It’s a collaboration among NewAssignment.Net, Wired, and those who choose to participate.

The investigation takes place in the open, not behind newsroom walls. Participation is voluntary; contributors are welcome from across the Web. The people getting, telling and vetting the story are a mix of professional journalists and members of the public — also known as citizen journalists. This is a model I describe as “pro-am.”

The “ams” are simply people getting together on their own time to contribute to a project in journalism that for their own reasons they support. The “pros” are journalists guiding and editing the story, setting standards, overseeing fact-checking, and publishing a final version.

In this project, we’re trying to crowdsource a single story, and debut a site that makes other such reports possible down the road. But we don’t know yet how well our site and our methods work. Our ideas are crude because they are untested. By participating, you can help us figure this puzzle out.

Interesting concept. If citizen journalism truly is alive in an age of digital media, then there should be a forum where citizen journalists can organize and collectively create news.

However, when looking through the tracker (where you go to look through recently filed reports), it seemed that much of Assignment Zero was focused on — surprise — citizen journalism. In a word, meta-journalism.

Two of the articles I looked at were “The Audience has the Power” (from the assignment “contextualize Bankler’s work”) and “A Contributor’s Perspective on Crowdsourced Journalism.” Both articles look that the study of community journalism. The first comes in terms of a summary of The Cult of the Amateur by Andrew Keen, while the second takes an empirical look at community journalism, citing political journalism crowdsourcing on the Daily Kos and TPM Muckraker; group endeavors with individual appeal, such as Assignment Zero; and geographically distributed local watchdogs.

All of this is interesting. However, I don’t think it lives up to the full promise and potential of the site. It may be that the premise is flawed. Maybe journalism works best when there is a single content creator synthesizing facts from multiple sources.

I’m not sure. We’ll have to see how this experiment plays out.



1. Jeni - August 17, 2007

Like you, Assignment Zero’s metajournalism was also the first thing that struck me about the site—it is crowdsourced journalism about crowdsourced journalism. You make a good point that, until this site really delves into a greater variety of news coverage, it is not living up to its potential as a journalistic endeavor. On the other hand, one of the main skepticisms surrounding grassroots journalism is lack of authority and credibility. At least with the news content we see so far on Assignment Zero, we can take heart in knowing they are pretty credible and can speak with some on authority on the topic (since they are engaging in it)!

2. sajadi4 - August 17, 2007

Steve–First of all, WOW! I’m surprised there was something on the internet you hadn’t heard of yet!! 🙂

In all seriousness, Assignment Zero is strange in that it compiles essays/interviews/articles from a variety of different people and puts it onto one site. It’s definitely an interesting idea, but I don’t think it has really taken off yet. Like Jeni said, there is the problem of authority and credibility–for me personally, this is why I’ve grown to be skeptical of blogs that act as news breakers (Hm..with the exception of Perez Hilton….)

I think that Assignment Zero is definitely on to an interesting concept; it just needs some tweaking and more work to make sure that it propels forward instead of getting stuck in cyperspace.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: